I have dark skin and aside from the brown pencil, the rest aren’t appealing on my face. One of them made me look like I had ashy lips (maybe I applied it wrong). The brown pencil complemented me.Issue: once you apply lip gloss or vaseline/acquafor on your lip, when you try to add the liner to ur lip, it doesn’t work. For some reason the color won’t come out (maybe bc of the oil?). It doesn’t seem to last long either. After lining my lips and applying lip gloss, a few hours later of not applying more lip gloss, I felt like my lips were crusting. It was the pencil.It’s best to use before applying lip gloss/vaseline…