Pleased with the colour and quality of the 'pencil', but using the templates is awkward and a pain.The way it goes on,the way it does cover upMy granddaughter really liked this as it’s her first time ever using this product.Don’t work as advertised.So I still do my own brows at home because I can’t afford all the fancy stuff yet but I do a decent job, anyway sometimes I royally mess up and I thought when I saw this that it was perfect for masking my mistakes.The eyebrow pens came just in time because I plucked just one too many and had a gap that desperately needed filling. It was tricky to angle it correctly with my natural brow angle and you defining needed both pens and even then I used a third brow product I already owned because as close as it was it just wasn’t cutting it however it did come close so I had to give it credit where credit is due. Glad to have them in the least but not sure id replace them in the future. 5/10I'm absolutely terrible at putting on my makeup despite me wearing makeup for 15 years. These do a great job to guide me and they look awesome after! I do not sweat them off and it last all day!For the price, this is pretty good. Definitely not a high end product, but if you don't want to spend the money, this is probably the way to go. I wouldn't exactly call it "waterproof." Maybe "water resistant." It goes on nicely and is going to last me a long time.The color I’d normally get didn’t match my skin tone or hair color at all. It was an odd brown that they sent. It looked cheap on me and I couldn’t fully test the product since I didn’t wear it around all day.